The Syrian Golan: Caught Between a Rock and a Hard Place

by Rory OConnell on June 21, 2012

We are delighted to welcome this guest post from Hannah Russell. Hannah is currently undertaking a PhD at Queen’s University, Belfast entitled the ‘Right to Life and European Conflicts’. She has worked for human rights organizations in Cambodia, Northern Ireland, Occupied Syrian Golan and Palestine. This has included working as a legal researcher and consultant for Al-Marsad – Arab Human Rights Centre in the Golan Heights.

The Syrian Golan: Caught Between a Rock and a Hard Place

As the world’s attention rightly turns to the developing civil war in Syria, a small piece of land less than 60km to the east of Damascus which has suffered over four decades of turmoil continues to be neglected. The Golan, home to rich water sources and fertile soil, is a mountainous region located in the southwest of Syria. The Golan is Syrian land which became illegally occupied by Israel in 1967 following the Arab-Israeli War and, following the implementation of the Israeli Golan Heights Law, has been illegally annexed by Israel since 1981.

Once home to 153,000 Syrians who were spread across two cities and over 200 villages and farms, the Golan now consists of only five Arab villages which are inhabited by 20,000 Syrians. Thousands have been permanently displaced to Syria proper and the ceasefire line has become impassable except to a select few, having all sorts of ramifications for families and the economy. Israel has taken full advantage of the circumstances including constructing and expanding illegal Jewish settlements within the region. At present there are 33 illegal settlements and a growing population of 20,000 illegal settlers in the Occupied Golan. Furthermore, the indigenous Arab population of the Golan is subject to discrimination in relation to taxes; water supplies; employment; economic opportunities; housing; and freedom of movement. Land has been expropriated; crops destroyed and access to land inhibited. All of this has been implemented by the Israeli authorities to the advantage of illegal Jewish settlers. In addition, the Syrian Arabs who have rejected Israeli citizenship (because to do so would result in denouncing their Syrian heritage and assist in cementing Israel’s illegal annexation) are denied passports and categorised as having “undefined” nationality.

As those with any knowledge of Israel and the occupied territories will have noticed discriminatory tactics used against Syrian Arabs are similar to those used against Palestinians in the occupied Palestinian territory. Yet the legal framework, political situation and violations of international law which exist in the Golan are different and for that reason require specific attention. Nevertheless, in reality the plight of Syrian Arabs tends to be merged with Palestinian grievances, to the point that the Golan’s story is neglected. Consequently those campaigning for recognition, equality and justice within the Golan face an additional challenge of trying to change this culture of generalisation that has developed within both political and humanitarian spheres.

The first organisation to be established within the Golan with the task of addressing the long-neglected human rights situation in the region is Al-Marsad – Arab Human Rights Centre in the Golan Heights. Al-Marsad works tirelessly to expose and challenge the violations of international law occurring within the Golan and is committed to doing so from a grass-roots point of view. It promotes a rights based approach as the way forward in addressing, highlighting and solving the problems facing the Syrian community of the Golan. Its actions include monitoring and documenting violations of international humanitarian and human rights laws, and providing a pro-bono legal service to the local Arab population. Issues that Al-Marsad has highlighted in the past and continues to work on include: illegality of Israel’s occupation/effective annexation of the Golan; expropriation of land; illegality of Jewish settlements; landmines; separation of families; discrimination; restriction on freedom of movement; and Israel’s exploitation of the local economy and resources.

For those interested in providing practical support Al-Marsad offers rolling internships for between three and six months – see http://www.golan-marsad.org/view.php?span_cat=108. While internships are unpaid, free accommodation is provided along with limitless hospitality and the invaluable experience of becoming part of the local community. As a small organization their interns become valued members of staff and, as a number of previous interns are testament to, it is a great way to develop your career in human rights. Previous interns have gone on to work as human rights specialists for non-governmental organizations, governmental organizations and United Nations bodies across the globe.

Conversations with locals over the last two years have indicated that until relatively recently Syria proper was put on a pedestal by the Arab population of the Golan. With recent developments the Golan is now caught between a rock and a hard place – on the one side living under the oppression and systematic discrimination of Israeli occupation, and on the other watching its homeland being torn apart and all the anxieties for family members and the future that comes with that. With its future increasingly uncertain, the Syrian population of the Golan’s fight for recognition, equality and justice (on both sides of the ceasefire line) seems all the more pertinent.

 

 

  • Patrick Corrigan

    Thanks Hannah. Very informative post about a largely ignored group of people who have had their rights violated for 45 years.

    I note that, in 2008, the United Nations General Assembly voted by 161-1 in favour of a motion on the “occupied Syrian Golan” that reaffirmed support for Security Council motion 497, which condemned the Golan Heights Law, extending Israeli law and administration throughout the Israeli-controlled territory.

    The international community decided: “the Israeli decision to impose its laws, jurisdiction and administration in the occupied Syrian Golan Heights is null and void and without international legal effect”.

    Sadly, Israel has flouted this UN decision, as it has so many others before and since. Ordinary people are left to suffer the consequences.

    More from Amnesty on Israel and the OPT here: http://www.amnesty.org.uk/content.asp?CategoryID=973

  • Hannah Russell

    Thank you Patrick for both your comment and Amnesty’s continued work in Israel and the Occupied Territories. Unfortunately, as you have highlighted, despite tens of resolutions specific to Israel’s occupation of the Syrian Golan being passed by the United Nations very little has been done to alleviate the problem on the ground. It is difficult to see an end to the oppression and the world’s ineffective actions on the matter. However there is a small step that organizations like Amnesty could take in helping to raise awareness of the Golan’s cause. That is an amendment to the terminology used when referring to the Golan and increasing its research in the area, which could be easily improved by speaking to grass roots organizations such as Al Marsad.

    In the report posted within your comment by Amnesty the Golan is mentioned once within a report entitled Israel and the OPT. This is disappointing on two counts. It does not reflect the identity of the Golan, as an occupied part of Syria. As the resolution you highlighted shows the Golan is not part of Israel, nor is it part of the Palestinian territory. Therefore, making it clear that when discussing Israel and its human rights violations the area should be referred to as Israel and the Occupied Territories. Furthermore, while the incidents on Nakba and Naksa Days 2011 are the most overt violations of human rights to have occurred in the Golan in a number of years, there are many other systematic violations that have continued since the occupation began in 1967 and should also be given coverage. Therefore, Amnesty’s report provides a disproportionate representation of the oppression that occurs against Syrian Arabs within the region.

    I understand that Amnesty is facing an uphill battle trying to raise awareness for human rights violations all around the world and I commend your work. I am happy to discuss this further in a more private sphere and put Amnesty in touch with people who could assist their work in the Golan.

Previous post:

Next post: